All Activity

Seems like the security check is flaky rather than the password rules. Weird that posting in the thread nudged it into working, but at least the account got through.

Windows 11 seems to expose every little bit of old UI behavior eventually. Link hover is one of those things that can look fine until someone actually tries to click through.

Nice to see the v2 version preserved here. Alt for horizontal feels a lot less awkward than retraining Shift muscle memory, and the middle-button pan bit is a handy extra.

Cross-posting itself is fine, but the missing link is what wastes everyone's time. One thread can easily end up with the actual fix while the other just goes quiet.

Ambiguous wording without any review turns it into more of a guess-the-test exercise. The missing completion screen is such an avoidable bit of friction too.

The no-review part makes the score feel pretty hollow, especially with questions that can be read two ways. A proper completion screen would have saved some needless inbox hunting too.

Getting only a pass or fail after an essay-heavy exam is pretty useless, especially when the retake lock sticks around that long. The score on the recert at least shows the fundamentals are clearly there.

CLAD is a separate certification exam, the free fundamentals quiz is more of a warm-up than the actual certificate.

Real-time is nice until you need to find that one answer from three weeks ago and it's buried under 400 messages of banter lol. Forums age better imo, Discord is where the traffic is these days though.

ngl undisclosed cross-posts are the worst, you sink time into an answer that's already sitting on the ni forum

I should also point out it is forum etiquette to state and link if a question is a cross-post on Ni.com. https://forums.ni.com/t5/Industrial-Communications/NI-9145-with-NI-9476-9375-in-TwinCAT/td-p/4485626

IIRC. There is a safe-mode that will set outputs to a safe value (presumably 0v for sourcing 24v) when active. However. I think the status LED of the controller should be blinking red to signify that. Apart from that. If a variable can be set but it's not being replicated in the slave device (the NI device is a slave, right?) then it points to a mismatch in the PDO mapping. I do not know how you would tell that from the XML files you supplied but you may know more about their construction than I.

This problem is not unique to mailing lists. Forums, StackOverflow, and official technical support channels still encounter them (although the modern channels do have more tools to deal with them).

Mailing lists were great for maintainers, horrendous for users. Waiting a week to see if your question was answered and trawling through the archives in case you missed a response. One's issue getting engulfed in spam of the same simple issues posted by different people over and over again. I'm glad the days of IRC, Mailing Lists and, hopefully, Discord, are way behind us. Even SQLite eventually dumped the mailing list and support has greatly improved because of it.

I never did the IRC thing, but started with mailing lists as the main support channel. I have quite fond memories of the Info-LabVIEW mailing list started by Tom Coradeschi and currently maintained by Scott Hannahs for posterity. Back when you had to actually connect a modem through your main telephone line in order to go onto the big, friendly (back then at least) internet, mailing lists were very handy as one could respond to the mails offline and then connect to the internet provider to send off all the mails in one batch.

Yeah, the real-time aspect of it does necessarily mean a tradeoff in other places. The LabVIEW Discord is quite well laid out though with sensible channels so we can keep discussion targeted. Personally I value the real-time aspect higher than the formal structure of a traditional forum so I (and many others these days) are gravitating to that kind of technology. It's definitely not perfect though!

IRC? Wow there is a blast from the past. Thank you for digging up some good old memories of many well spent nights spent at my university computer lab arguing with other randos on the internet about alien activity and other tin foil hat stuff 🤣 I did not realise that is where all the LabVIEW developers had gone...

Thanks @Neil Pate! I posted here in the #announcements channel - please let me know if there are any other channels where I should post. https://discord.com/channels/1015999107921354932/1017172031499944037/1549893327971688601 Best, JP

Hi all, Thanks for the input. Sorry I missed the first few replies. As for now, I've already create an NI technical support case on this problem. I also tried NI forum before with no luck.

Discord is a poor support platform and I view Discord with the same contempt as IRC (and for similar reasons). If one thinks Lavag.org is a sub-optimal platform with little activity; answer the question or suggest posting the same question on NI.com. EtherCAT is a niche expertise and if you can't find help here or on NI.com, I very much doubt you will find it on your Discord server.

It is a pity you don't get on so well with Discord, your presence over there is sorely missed.

Both! NI's implementation of EtherCAT leaves a lot to be desired. As to Discord, it's not really the people on there but I just can't seem to manage and keep an overview on the various threads in Discord. Partly that is because I mostly look at it on mobile, but in a webbrowser on the PC it's not that much better, despite the bigger screen.

Because of the people on Discord or because of NI's implementation of EtherCAT? 😉

Unlikely.

@Gabriel Utomo there is not much activity on LAVA these days. You might have more success if you post on the LabVIEW Discord http://discord.gg/labview