Jump to content
MikaelH

SubPanel

Recommended Posts

I have an issue with a Sub Panel in a generic GUI VI we use as part of our company's OO based application framework.

Most often the SubPanel behaves like it should.

But sometimes after the application has stopped, the VI that was last inserted into the SubPanel, is still inserted according to LV.
When this happens (and I start the application again) I can't insert that VI into the SubPanel again, I can insert other VIs, but if I try to insert the last Inserted VI, LV says:
Error 1145: Cannot open VI because it is already in a subpanel control.

If I try to open the VI's FP, LV opens the FP of the GUI VI that has the SubPanel (just like it should if it was inserted), but the SubPanel is Empty.
And LV behaves the same, even after the SW stopped?!?!
When LV stops all SubPanels should be emptied (i.e.all inserted VIs should be thrown out.)

 

Has anybody else experienced this strange behavior?

Our framework is doing something that LV doesn't like of, but I haven't figured it out yet.

We do see one strange behavior as well.
We start up the framework with a VI that kicks off some processes (just like you do in Actor Framework), and when the framework starts up and starts inserting stuff in the SubPanels, the Top VI becomes broken, but it's still running.

Have you guys seen this as well?
Framework.png

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, MikaelH said:

Most often the SubPanel behaves like it should.

But sometimes after the application has stopped, the VI that was last inserted into the SubPanel, is still inserted according to LV.
When this happens (and I start the application again) I can't insert that VI into the SubPanel again, I can insert other VIs, but if I try to insert the last Inserted VI, LV says:
Error 1145: Cannot open VI because it is already in a subpanel control.

If I try to open the VI's FP, LV opens the FP of the GUI VI that has the SubPanel (just like it should if it was inserted), but the SubPanel is Empty.
And LV behaves the same, even after the SW stopped?!?!
When LV stops all SubPanels should be emptied (i.e.all inserted VIs should be thrown out.)

When you say "LV stops", I'm guessing you mean you stop your VI and return to Edit mode? Note that LabVIEW itself doesn't stop.

Anyway, are you talking about cleanly shutting down your VI, or aborting it?

  • If clean shutdown: Does it help if you make your framework explicitly un-insert subpanels during shutdown?
  • If abort: I'd guess it's a reference that wasn't released properly.

 

1 hour ago, MikaelH said:

We start up the framework with a VI that kicks off some processes (just like you do in Actor Framework), and when the framework starts up and starts inserting stuff in the SubPanels, the Top VI becomes broken, but it's still running.

Have you guys seen this as well?
Framework.png

I haven't seen this, but it looks like a bug.

As @Aristos Queue said in https://lavag.org/topic/20315-xnodes-prevent-inlining/#comment-123550 -- "Only squeaky wheels get grease", so do submit a reproducible example to NI if you can! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I mean when the VI finish, and it goes back to edit mode.

I do stop all the VIs in a clean way, and ask them to be remove from the sub panels before the Vi finish.

I will try to create a small application that shows the issue to NI.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I see this "Running but broken".  I also see cases where a VI LV thinks is deployed is a different version from the one actually deployed.  Or VIs bein broken because of errors in VIs which aren't even used on the target..... I've had RT VIs claim they were broken due to an error in a VI which is only used on our FPGA targets..... Something somewhere is very weird with the whole handling of these things.  I've been harping on about it for years and I'm glad (please don't take that the wrong way) that others are starting to see the same problems.  Maybe eventually it'll get fixed.

 

Of course, the problem is tat in making a small example, the problem tends to go away nicely. NI really should have a mobile customer liaison (a crack LV debugger) who travels around visiting customers with such non-reproducible problems in order to get dirty with debug tools and find out what is going on.  There are so many issues which will never be fixed because the act of paring it down for NI "fixes" the problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By AInvisibleNinja
      I'm trying to run a VI using the Call by Reference function, then embedded it into a subpanel in my Main.VI. Once the VI is embedded, I can't use it in the subpanel. It's like everything is blocked and it won't let me interact with any of it. If I use an invoke node and call the Run VI method, this isn't an issue. Unfortunately, this is part of a much bigger application that use Call by Reference functions, so I can't replace those calls.
       
      I have attach image snippets showing my code. Does anyone have any suggestions why this might be happening or a work-around to fix it? Thank you in advance!


    • By RnDMonkey
      I see a lot of knowledgeable minds around here, so here's my challenge. I have a test system that will have, at the user interface level per channel, 3 inputs and 2 outputs that together encompass a simple test scenario. I would like that scheme repeated up to 10 times in a single application so you could watch a bank of units under test, allowing both scripted or manual manipulation of inputs; plus viewing and logging of the outputs.
       
      Here is an example of what I think I want the user to interact with:

       
      I would like to associate each of these "subpanels" (not to be confused with actual subpanels - yet) with a LabVIEW class object that will handle the interface with hardware. All channels would be coordinated by a top-level VI (let's call it the Controller) that aggregates the channels and provides the ability to parse script files to press buttons and stuff. Here's where I'm having trouble, conceptually. One solution seems to be to spin off a new asynchronous call-and-collect VI (in the form of the pictured panel as a brat VI) that has the brat throw its control references into a queue for the Controller to catch and store for later access. The brat would receive stuff like a user stop event and the hardware session's class object when first called. I would then create an array a grid of 10 Sub Panel controls on the Controller's front panel and place each brat VI into its own Sub Panel like a facade.
       
      The core of the hardware IO would be built into the brat VI (operating on the class objects), with the Controller pulling the strings and catching outputs and user interaction through dynamically registered events and property nodes operating on the brat's references. This all seems like it should all be workable and isn't fundamentally new to me.
       
      Does this seem reasonable?
       
      Another - much less (in)formed - concept I had was to avoid the ACBR brat structure entirely and implement this "subpanel" as an XControl that I can treat like a regular control on my Controller's front panel. I think of XControls because I can't have a cluster with both inputs and ouputs (unless I access the indicators with property nodes and fake it, I think), though I am actually only assuming that XControls allow both at once, or the equivalent behavior. In this scenario, the controller would retain an array of my hardware session's class objects and index them associated with each control. This way, the controller would invoke a hardware IO operation in a for loop to iterate across all devices. Similarly, when one of the XControls had a button clicked, the controller would see the value change event, figure out which one fired it, and do some function for only that associated hardware.
       
      I've never implemented an XControl before - at all - so the first solution is going to be the easier one for me. Is there a good argument for going the XControl route over the asynchronous-brats-with-Sub-Panel route?
       
      Thank you for your inputs, and sorry for the wall of text!
    • By ensegre
      I ran into this; I wonder if I'm misunderstanding, or it's a bug.
       

       
      I have a FP, with buttons I want to toggle with keys, and I have string controls in a subpanel, like in the attached minimal example. I'd like to toggle the button while the focus remains in the subpanel string. While this is no problem for a control on the FP, pressing F1 while focus is in the subpanel string rises the focus to the whole subpanel container. What is wrong? If a bug, how to workaround? Setting KeyFocus to the sbubpanel string ref doesn't seem to help.
       
      Seen in 2014SP1 linux and 2014SP1f3 windows.
      main.vi
      subvi.vi
    • By Manudelavega
      Is there a way to retrieve the reference of the VI inserted in a subpanel? I'm writing a code that takes a "parent" VI ref, and then scan through all its splitters, panes, and subpanels, and now I'd like to retrieve some infos from the VIs loaded inside the subpanels...
       
      Cheers
    • By stgranger
      Hello,
       
      I am working on a user interface for an 8 site test station.  I put a lot of thought into the design of the UI and when I started trying to implement, I ran into a major road block and was hoping I could get some advice here. Here is an overview of what I have:
       
      I have 1 view where I want to see an overview of all 8 sites and have basic control of each site.  Each site can test part A or B.  Each part has different information and therefore, I want the overview display to be different for each, depending on which part number is being tested.  
       
      So I made a "Part" Class and 2 child classes "A" and "B".  Each child class has an "overview" VI that has the information that I would like to display.  My plan was for each site to create an instance of the appropriate class ("A" or "B") and insert the "overview" VI into the subpanel corresponding to the appropriate site.  
       
      This is where I ran into a problem.  I load part A into site 1, and the subpanel loads the correct display.  Then I try to load a second part A in site 2, and I get an error saying I can't load that VI because it is already loaded in another subpanel.  I had assumed that if I had a reentrant VI and had created multiple instances of it, that I could insert each instance into a separate subpanel. 
       
      After searching on the NI website, I found an article saying that this is not possible.  I guess I made a bad assumption when I went down this path.  Does anybody have any recommendations for alternatives? Or any way around this?  Thanks! 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.